Skip to main content
Version: 6.x

Migrating from ink! 4.x to 5.0

We've made a couple of breaking changes from ink! 4.x to ink! 5.0. On this page we outline how you can migrate existing dApps and contracts from 4.x to 5.0.

This release addresses the majority of issues raised in the OpenZeppelin security review. In particular, we addressed the proxy selector clashing attack.

You can find the full changelog of the 5.0 release here.

caution

This migration guide only considers your code base! Not your storage data!

If you have an existing contract on-chain you might not be able to just upgrade the code on-chain, you possibly also have to migrate your storage data.

The relevant change that you have to take into consideration is #1897. A data migration may be required when your contract reads data from storage and truncates the data when decoding it. We've described this in more detail below, in the section "Fail when decoding from storage and not all bytes consumed".

How to upgrade​

  • Change the dependency versions of ink and ink_e2e in your contracts Cargo.toml to 5.
  • Update your local cargo-contract installation to 4.0.
  • Read through this page.

Compatibility​

Substrate/Polkadot SDK​

There are four new functions that are only compatible from particular releases upwards:

  • v2 of call and instantiate: >= polkadot-v1.8.0 and substrate-contracts-node >= v0.39.0 (explained here).
  • lock_delegate_dependency and unlock_delegate_dependency: >= polkadot-v1.9.0 and substrate-contracts-node >= v0.40.0 (explained here).

These four functions are all opt-in! None of them are required to use ink! 5.0, they are only required if you want to access the particular functionality they provide. Please see the linked explainers for more details about them.

If you are not using any of those four functions, the same requirements as for ink! 4.0 holds:

  • pallet-contracts >= polkadot-v0.9.37.
  • substrate-contracts-node >= v0.24.0

How do I find out if a chain is compatible with ink! 5?​

You can query contracts::palletVersion() via the chain state RPCs. It has to be >= 9 for ink! 5.0 to be compatible, if you don't use any of the four functions mentioned above. For the above mentioned four functions please see the respective sections on this page, there we explain how to find out if a chain supports them there.

You can use the polakdot.js app to do this: Developer » Chain State » contracts » palletVersion() » Click on the + on the right.

The following chains are in production and support ink! 5.0, if you are not using any of the four functions mentioned above:

cargo-contract 4.0​

Together with ink! 5.0 we've released cargo-contract 4.0.

info

You have to use cargo-contract >= 4.0 for ink! 5.0 contracts!

You can upgrade via:

cargo install cargo-contract --version ^4

Make sure that e.g. your CI also uses at least cargo-contract 4.0 with ink! v5.0. If you have wrapper scripts around cargo-contract, you should ensure that this version is enforced, otherwise users will get an error.

Tooling & Libraries​

  • Stable Rust >= 1.75
  • cargo-contract >= v4.0
  • polkadot-js/api and polkadot-js/api-contract >= 10.12.1
  • use-inkathon: upgrade the polkadot-js/api and polkadot-js/api-contract dependencies in your project to >= 10.12.1
  • ink!athon >= 0.7.0
  • typechain-polkadot >= 1.2.0

Important Changes​

We had to introduce a number of changes that require you to manually upgrade your contract from 4.x to 5.0. The steps to do this are explained in this section.

scale dependencies were moved to ink entrance crate​

This change was done to ensure that you always use the correct scale dependency versions with an ink! version. The relevant PR is #1890.

We removed the requirement for contracts to have direct dependencies on parity-scale-codec and scale-info in their Cargo.toml. You can now remove those dependencies from your contracts Cargo.toml:

ink = { version = "4.3", default-features = false }
-scale = { package = "parity-scale-codec", version = "3", default-features = false, features = ["derive"] }
-scale-info = { version = "2.6", default-features = false, features = ["derive"], optional = true }

Both crates have been re-exported from the ink umbrella crate: ink::scale_info and ink::scale.

We created a convenience macro to derive the re-exported traits ink::scale::Encode, ink::scale::Decode and ink::scale_info::TypeInfo.

// Previously
#[scale::Encode, scale::Decode)]
#[cfg_attr(feature = "std", derive(::scale_info::TypeInfo))]
pub enum Error {}


// Now
#[ink::scale_derive(Encode, Decode, TypeInfo)]
pub enum Error {}

The documentation of the macro can be found here.

Wildcard selectors: only one other message is allowed in the contract besides the wildcard selector​

Following our security review by OpenZeppelin, we've tightened the usage of wildcard selectors. With ink! 5.0 we allow only exactly one other contract message with a well-known reserved selector to be defined. In ink! 4.x, more than one other message was allowed.

Read more in the PR and IIP-2: Limit contracts with a wildcard selector to one other message.

The proposal is to restrict contracts with a wildcard selector to only have one other message with a reserved/well-known selector. This guarantees that there are no selector clashes, either by chance or malicious intent, and that the Proxy will only handle messages intended for it.

If a contract uses a wildcard selector #[ink(message, payable, selector = _)] it MAY define one other message. This message MUST use the reserved selector @. This selector MUST only be used in conjunction with a wildcard selector.

/// Handles any message with no matching selector in this proxy contract
#[ink(message, selector = _)]
pub fn fallback(&self) {
    // forward call to the "logic" contract which actually executes the call
}

#[ink::scale_derive(Decode)]
pub enum ProxyMessage {
    UpgradeContract(Hash),
}

/// One other message allowed to handle messages.
/// Fails to compile unless `@` is used as the selector.
#[ink(message, selector = @)]
pub fn handler(&self, msg: ProxyMessage) {
  match msg {
    ProxyMessage(hash) => { }
  }
}

/// An additional message. Fails to compile when uncommented.
// #[ink(message)]
// pub fn additional_message(&self, msg: ProxyMessage) {
//    match msg {
//        ProxyMessage(hash) => ...
//    }
// }

Events 2.0​

In prior ink! versions, events were defined inside the #[ink::contract] macro. With ink! 5.0 we decouple events from the #[ink::contract] macro, allowing events to be shared between contracts. We've updated the Events documentation page accordingly.

The syntax of defining events within the main #[ink::contract] macro will continue to work, no code changes in existing contracts are required to update to the new syntax.

caution

The topic calculation changed in general, so also for events that are declared inside the #[ink::contract] macro!

This is a breaking change for any client code which uses topics to filter events.

Please see #1827 for details.

Custom signature topics​

In #2031 we introduced an optional attribute signature_topic to the #[ink::event] and #[ink(event)] macros. It can be used to specify the signature topic for a specific event manually, instead of the automatic topic calculation.

No more unchecked arithmetic​

Unchecked arithmetic operations in a contract are no longer supported for arithmetic safety reasons. Compiling a contract that contains those will fail gracefully.

If you haven't already done, you now need to handle overflows that could occur. Rust supports different possibilities of doing so (saturating, "wrap around", and unchecked arithmetic operations) . See this section of the Rust Programming Language for a thorough explanation on how to do safe arithmetic operations in Rust.

This change was introduced in #1831.

Fail when decoding from storage and not all bytes consumed​

If a contract previously relied on successful decoding which does not consume all bytes, then recompiling with a version of ink! which includes this change will cause that contract to trap at runtime when attempting to decode.

A simple example would be if a storage cell contains some bytes which were in the first place an encoded u32. If the contract attempts to decode those into a u8 this would previously have succeeded, now the contract would trap.

Here's a code example of behavior that previously worked for ink! 4.x, but would error now:

let key = 0u32;
let value = [0x42; 32];
ink::env::set_contract_storage(&key, &value);

// Only attempt to read the first byte (the `u8`) of the storage value data
let _loaded_value: Option<u8> = ink::env::get_contract_storage(&key)
    .map_err(|e| format!("get_contract_storage failed: {:?}", e))?;

We introduced this change in #1897.

[ink_e2e] API Changes​

Builder API​

In #1917 we reworked the E2E API with a builder API. instantiate, call and upload will now return a builder instance. You can specify optional arguments with builder methods, and submit the call for on-chain execution with the .submit() method, or dry-run it with dry_run().

let contract = client
    .instantiate("flipper", &ink_e2e::alice(), &mut constructor)
    .submit()
    .await
    .expect("instantiate failed");
let mut call_builder = contract.call_builder::<Flipper>();

let get = call_builder.get();
let get_res = client.call(&ink_e2e::bob(), &get).dry_run().await;
assert!(matches!(get_res.return_value(), false));

Extra gas margin​

As part of #1917 we added the possibility to specify a gas margin (in percentage) as part of the on-chain call.

There are cases when gas estimates may not necessarily be accurate enough due to the complexity of the smart contract logic that adds additional overhead and gas consumption. Therefore, it is helpful to allow to specify an extra portion of the gas to be added to the limit (i.e. 5%, 10%).

The method .extra_gas_portion(margin: u64) method is part of the builder API:

Improved call() API​

We removed the build_message() function with its unhandy callback.

// Previously
let first_insert = ink_e2e::build_message::<MappingsRef>(contract_id)
    .call(|contract| contract.insert_balance(1_000));

// Now
let first_insert = ink_e2e::build_message::<MappingsRef>(contract_id)
    .call().insert_balance(1_000));

See #1782 for more details.

Removed additional_contracts parameter​

additional_contracts parameter which is part of #[ink_e2e:test] has been removed in #2098. This information is now implied from the contract's manifest. Simply, add the other contract as dependency with the ink-as-a-dependency feature enabled. The test will detect the contract and build it as part of the test.

In #2076, we've added a new remove_code function to the E2E API:

let contract = client
    .remove_code(&ink_e2e::alice(), code_hash)
    // Submit the call for on-chain execution.
    .submit()
    .await
    .expect("remove failed");

New Data Structure: StorageVec​

We've added a Vec-like data structure, built on top of Mapping.

This allows to retrieve elements from a vector and grow it without having to load and push all elements. For Vec, the cost of reading or writing a single element grows linearly corresponding to the number of elements in the vector (its length). Additionally, the maximum capacity of the whole vector is limited by the size of ink!'s static buffer used during ABI encoding and decoding (default 16 KiB). StorageVec on the other hand allows to access each element individually.

With a Vec it's possible to e.g. introduce a security issue in your contract where an attacker can fill the Vec, making it very costly for other users to access it or write to it.

You can find verbatim documentation on StorageVec here. The page explains when to use StorageVec and when not. The Rust docs can be found here.

Fallible methods for Lazy, Mapping, StorageVec​

In #1910 we added try_* methods for reading and writing Lazy and Mapping values to and from storage. The try methods correspond to Mapping::{insert, get, take}, Lazy::{set, get}. For StorageVec::{peek, get, set, pop, push} we added try_* methods in #1995.

Please see the individual Rust docs for these new methods:

You should use the try_* methods for dynamically sized values, unless you made sure otherwise they will fit into the static buffer. The static buffer in ink! is 16 kB by default.

We added a lint to cargo-contract 4.0 that will detect potentially unsafe uses of methods for which there are safer alternatives: non_fallible_api.

Chain Extension API changed + Support for multiple chain extensions​

With #1958 we added support for interacting with multiple chain extensions from ink!. This is a breaking change.

You can now e.g. have a contract that utilizes a PSP22 chain extension together with one for random numbers.

The syntax for chain extension functions changed slightly:

-#[ink(extension = 0xfecb)]
+#[ink(function = 0xfecb)]
fn foo() {}

The argument type changed from u32 to u16:

-/// `#[ink(extension = N: u32)]`
-Extension,
+/// `#[ink(function = N: u16)]`
+Function,

The top level macro #[ink::chain_extension] now requires an (extension = N: u16) argument to support multiple chain extensions. If you are using only one extension, the ID can be any u16 number, otherwise please consult the #[ink::chain_extension] macro documentation

-#[ink::chain_extension]
+#[ink::chain_extension(extension = 1)]
note

If the chain extension was not used in a tuple in the runtime configuration, extension = N: u16 can take any u16 number.

A migration in most cases should just be to rename #[ink(extension = …)] to #[ink(function = …)], and specifying extension argument in top level macro.

We added an example contract that illustrates the usage of multiple chain extensions in one contract: combined-extension.

call and instantiate v2​

The functions to instantiate and call other contracts got an upgrade in the polkadot-v1.8.0 release (in the d250a6 commit), The new v2 of them allows passing both Weight parts (ref_time_limit and proof_size_limit), as well as the storage_deposit_limit.

The previous v1 call and instantiate functions only provided a single gas_limit parameter, which was used as the value for ref_time_limit. You can still use these v1 versions. For call on a call builder obtained through build_call:

call_builder
  .call_v1()
  .gas_limit(ref_time_limit)
  .invoke();

For instantiate on build_create:

The new v2 parameters can be set like so:

call_builder // or `create_builder`
  .ref_time_limit(ref_time_limit)
  .proof_size_limit(proof_size_limit)
  .storage_deposit_limit(storage_deposit_limit)
  .invoke();

You can find out if a chain supports the new v2 functions for call/instantiate by querying the contracts::apiVersion constant. It has to be 1. You can use the polakdot.js app to do this: Developer » Chain State » Constants » contracts » apiVersion » Click on the + on the right.

At the time of the ink! v5 release (March 2024) no parachain with ink! support had upgraded to polkadot-v1.8.0 yet.

Please note that if you are using trait definitions for cross-contract calls, direct calls from the contract_ref! macro are only supported with the call_v2. Otherwise, you need to get the CallBuilder from the structure and build the call manually.

type Erc20Wrapper = contract_ref!(Erc20);
let erc20: Erc20Wrapper = new_erc20.into();
let erc20_builder = erc20.call();
erc20_builder.total_supply().call_v1().invoke()

Metadata Changes​

Events 2.0​

See #1827 for the full details. Two fields werere added to the objects in the events array: module_path and signature_topic.

Previously the order of the events in the events array was significant (i.e. the first one had an implied index of 0), and this index could be used to determine which event to decode. Now that is replaced by the signature_topic, and the order of the events in the metadata no longer has any significance.

See the section "Events 2.0" on this page for more info.

ink! 4.0:

   "events": [
      {
        "args": [ ... ],
        "docs": [ ... ],
        "label": "Transfer"
      },
      ...
  ]

ink! 5.0:

    "events": [
      {
        "args": [ ... ],
        "docs": [ ... ],
        "label": "...",
+       "module_path": "erc20::erc20",
+       "signature_topic": "0xb5b61a3e6a21a16be4f044b517c28ac692492f73c5bfd3f60178ad98c767f4cb"
      },
      ...
  ]

New field: staticBufferSize​

With #1880 we added a "staticBufferSize" field to the metadata file. The unit is bytes.

See the section "Buffer size can be customized" on this page for more info.

Example:

      "maxEventTopics": 4,
+     "staticBufferSize": 16384,
      "timestamp": { ... }

Metadata storage keys encoding change​

Storage keys used to access storage data are SCALE encoded. Previously, the contract metadata used big endian encoding to represent storage keys. With the ink! 5.0 release, these encoding formats have been aligned, and SCALE encoding (little endian) is now used for the metadata storage keys. This is a breaking change, and client tools that use the storage keys from contract metadata will need to adapt accordingly.

Please see: #2048 for details.

Example:

    "storage": {
        "root": {
        "layout": {
            "struct": {
            "fields": [
                {
                "layout": {
                    "leaf": {
-                   "key": "0x00000159",
+                   "key": "0x59010000",
                    "ty": 0
                    }
                },
                "name": "value"
                }
            ],
            "name": "Flipper"
            }
        },
-       "root_key": "0x00000159",
+       "root_key": "0x59010000",
        "ty": 1
        }
    },

Interesting New Features​

End-To-End testing with a chain snapshot​

With ink! 5.0 we introduce the possibility of running your tests against the fork (i.e. snapshot) of a live chain.

See this page in our documentation for details.

New lints​

The new lints are:

With cargo-contract 4.0 we added a couple new lints for common smart contract issues and best practices. You can run the linter via cargo contract build --lint.

Details on each lint can be found here.

New cargo-contract commands​

We added a bunch of helpful new commands to cargo-contract 4.0. For all these commands you can also supply the --help cli flag to get more info (e.g. cargo contract storage --help).

  • cargo contract verify: contract verification (#1404, #1306)
  • cargo contract info now outputs the language of the deployed contract, using a heuristic (#1329)
  • cargo contract info --binary: outputs the on-chain Wasm of the contract (#1311)
  • cargo contract info --all: displays all addresses of deployed contracts on a particular chain (#1319)
  • cargo contract storage: displays the storage of an on-chain contract (#1395, #1414)

Alternative off-chain E2E testing backend support: DRink!​

DRink! is a toolbox for ink! developers that allows for testing your contracts without any running node.

It has a number of features that are pretty great:

  • deploy and call your contracts synchronously, without any delays related to block production or networking.
  • enhanced debugging and call tracing.
  • supports arbitrary runtime configurations, including custom chain extensions and runtime calls.
  • full control over runtime state, including block number, timestamp, etc.

See the DRink! page for more details.

Contract Verification​

We added a bunch of helpful documentation and cargo-contract commands for contract verification. Read more here.

We improved the contract example illustrating upgradeable contracts via delegate_call​

See here for the contract example.

Upgradeable Contracts: delegate_dependency​

We've added support for two new host functions:

  • lock_delegate_dependency: prevents the code at the given code hash from being removed.
  • unlock_delegate_dependency: releases the lock on preventing the code from being removed from the current contract.

Having a delegate dependency allows contracts to safely delegate to another code_hash with the guarantee that it cannot be deleted.

We've updated the upgradeable-contracts/delegator example to demonstrate these new calls. For that purpose we've also added a remove_code function to the E2E API.

These two functions are only available from polkadot-1.8.0 on. You can find out if a chain supports these new functions by querying the contracts::apiVersion constant. It has to be 2. You can use the polakdot.js app to do this: Developer » Chain State » Constants » contracts » apiVersion » Click on the + on the right.

At the time of the ink! v5 release (March 2024) no parachain with ink! support had upgraded to polkadot-v1.8.0 yet.

We made set_code_hash generic​

The self.env().set_code_hash() method now accepts the Hash environment type instead of a concrete [u8; 32].

// Previously
pub fn set_code(&mut self, code_hash: [u8; 32]) {
    ink::env::set_code_hash(&code_hash).unwrap_or_else(|err| {});
}

// Now
pub fn set_code(&mut self, code_hash: Hash) {
    self.env().set_code_hash(&code_hash).unwrap_or_else(|err| {});
}

More details in #1906.

Buffer size can be customized​

With #1869 we added a possibility of setting a custom static buffer size for ink! to use.

ink! uses a static buffer for interacting with pallet-contracts, i.e. to move data between pallet-contracts and a smart contract. The advantage of a static buffer is that no gas-expensive heap allocations are necessary, all allocations are done using simple pointer arithmetic.

The default static buffer size is 16 kB, which is enough for on-chain smart contracts. However, the Phala Network parachain on Polkadot allows the deployment of ink! contracts off-chain. Hence, for their chain certain high computation contracts might require a larger buffer size.

Stabilized call_runtime​

We stabilized call_runtime in #1749. It can be used to call a runtime dispatchable from an ink! contract.

You can find a contract example and a comparison with chain extensions here. We've added an example of how to end-to-end test call_runtime here.